The Sanctuary

Writing about interests; Computer Science, Philosophy, Physics, Mathematics and AI.

A World Elsewhere

philosophymachiavellityrannypowerpoliticshistory

On a kingdom safe from everyone inside it.

I. By Favour and Permission

Every prince wants the same thing of his kingdom, and few will say it aloud: that nobody in it should be able to overthrow him. Not that nobody should wish to, since wishes are cheap and he made his peace with them long ago, but that nobody should be able to, which is a matter of arrangement rather than affection, and therefore within his reach. The arrangement is old and simple. He removes from the kingdom every power that does not derive from him: the lord with men of his own, the city with walls of its own, the family with a name older than his, the general the soldiers love, the minister the people know. In their place he puts men who hold everything by his favour and can lose it by his displeasure, and he moves them about often enough that none of them takes root. When he has finished there is no one in the country who could rise against him, because there is no one in the country who could rise. He has cut every ear that stood above the rest of the field, and he sleeps.

Machiavelli described the result in the fourth chapter of The Prince, and gave it a name that has not improved with age. Principalities, he observes, are governed in one of two ways: by a prince and barons, who hold their rank by blood and not by his grace, or “by a prince, with a body of servants, who assist him to govern the kingdom as ministers by his favour and permission”. His example of the first was the King of France, set among ancient lords whom their own subjects acknowledge and love; of the second, the Turk, who divides his kingdom into provinces and “sends there different administrators, and shifts and changes them as he chooses”. Then comes the verdict the prince has been waiting for. The kingdom of servants is hard to take, because “the usurper cannot be called in by the princes of the kingdom”: its ministers are slaves and bondmen, hard to corrupt and of little use when corrupted, since “they cannot carry the people with them”. France is the opposite. An invader enters it by gaining over a baron, and there is always a baron to be gained.

Few pages in the literature of power have done as much for a prince’s sleep. This one certifies his labour on the highest authority in the trade: a kingdom emptied of barons cannot be sold from within, because there is nobody inside with anything to sell. He reads it and closes the book, which is a pity, since it was not written for him. Machiavelli addressed the chapter to the man on the other side of the frontier, the conqueror deciding which of his neighbours to take, and the conqueror who reads to the end of it finds there a promise the prince has never noticed. A kingdom of servants is hard to subvert from within, and for the same reason it is easy to subvert from without. These are not two facts, a benefit and a price to be set against it. They are one fact, read from the two sides of a frontier: whatever makes it impossible for a subject to stand against his prince makes it impossible for him to stand against anyone. The prince has not removed a danger from his kingdom. He has changed its address, from his subjects to his neighbours, and paid for the move himself.

He does not see it, and the reason is not stupidity. He is a realist, and proud of it. He knows exactly what his subjects could do to him, because he has spent his reign making sure they cannot, and he counts each removal as a householder counts the bolts on his door. His private conviction is not that he is loved, nor even that he is strong. It is subtler, and more flattering: that he has found the best of both worlds, which lesser men suppose not to exist. He means to keep Machiavelli’s two kingdoms at once, the Turk’s when he looks inward and the King of France’s when he looks out, with servants at home who cannot rise against him and barons at the frontier who will rise for him. He has one population to do it with. A danger nobody inside his kingdom is able to carry out seems to him a danger that has ceased to exist, and the belief holds of every danger but one; that one has the patience of geography. His kingdom is safe from everyone inside it, for the excellent reason that there is no longer anyone inside it.

II. The Same Hands

The prince’s arithmetic rests on a distinction he never examines: that among the strengths of his subjects some are dangerous and some are useful, and that he may remove the first and keep the second. The distinction is imaginary. Strength in a subject has no fixed direction. The lord who can raise a thousand men against his king can raise them against an invader; the town whose walls could hold out against the prince’s army could hold out against a foreign one; the general whom the soldiers would follow to the capital is the only general they would follow to the frontier; the minister with credit among the people is the only one who could ask the people for anything in a bad year. Every quality that makes a subject worth fearing makes him worth having, because all of them come to the same thing, the power to act without permission, and it is precisely this power that the prince removes. He cannot remove it in one direction only. Only the will of the man who holds it gives it a direction, and the will is the one thing the prince has decided not to rely on. A servant who can raise no men against his master can raise none for him either.

How a realist comes to miss this is a question for the logicians, who have an old name for the error. Among the arguments Eubulides of Miletus raised in dialectic was one called the Man in a Veil, and unlike its neighbour the Liar it did not survive inspection: it has long since been moved from the paradoxes to the fallacies. You say you know Socrates; you admit you do not know the veiled man in the corner; but the veiled man is Socrates. The error is to take a fact about the knower for a fact about the man, and the prince commits it in its purest form. He fears the subject who could overthrow him; he has no fear of the subject who would defend his frontier; therefore, he concludes, they are two subjects, and he may remove the first and keep the second. His fear is a fact about the prince. On the day of the invasion the veil comes off, and the two subjects turn out to have been one man all along, and absent.

Machiavelli wrote down both halves of the truth, and kept them in separate sentences. The French lords, beloved by their own people, are what let an invader in; they are also what keep him from settling, since after his victory “the lords that remain make themselves the heads of fresh movements against you”, and he holds the kingdom only until the next occasion. The kingdom of servants is the same equation with the signs reversed: no lord to open the gate, and none to fight on once it has been forced. He presented this as four facts about two kingdoms. It is one fact about power. The strength that can turn against a prince is the only strength that can turn against his enemies, and a kingdom has exactly as much of the second as it has kept of the first.

Sparta tried to have it both ways, and Thucydides recorded the attempt in a single chapter. With an Athenian garrison at Pylos and the Helots restless, the Spartans proclaimed that those Helots who claimed to have done best against the enemy should be picked out and freed. It was a test, since “it was thought that the first to claim their freedom would be the most high-spirited and the most apt to rebel”. Two thousand were chosen, crowned themselves, went round the temples, and were soon afterwards done away with, “and no one ever knew how each of them perished”. In the same chapter the Spartans “gladly sent seven hundred as heavy infantry” to fight in the north. One test had served both purposes, and could not have done otherwise, since the quality that marked a Helot for the grave was the quality that fitted him for the line of battle; the city spent it at home and abroad as though it could tell the two apart.

Rivalry is the same strength in the plural, and the prince removes it for the same reasons. Machiavelli, writing the history of his own city, set Rome beside Florence and found the whole difference in what each had done with its quarrels: “A new law settled the disputes of Rome; those of Florence were only terminated by the death and banishment of many of her best people. Those of Rome increased her military virtue, while that of Florence was quite extinguished by her divisions.” The quarrel was the same. Rome settled it inside the walls, by a law, and kept both parties; Florence settled it at the gate. The city that kept its rivals could fight, and the city that put them out could not. Montesquieu, looking at Rome from the far end of its history, stated the rule that a prince most needs and least wants to hear: “To ask, in a free state, for men who are bold in war and timid in peace, is to desire impossible things.” The prince asks for exactly this, without the inconvenience of the free state: subjects who are lions at the frontier and lambs in the capital, a courage that can be switched off at the city gate and on again at the border. There is no such switch. There is only the courage, and the prince must decide whom he would rather it were used against. Having decided that it must never be used against him, he has decided the rest without noticing.

Much of Machiavelli’s fame rests on formulas of the same kind, which offer the profits of two worlds for the price of one. The prince is to be feared and not hated, since “he can endure very well being feared whilst he is not hated”; he is to seem merciful, faithful, humane, religious and upright, and even to be so, “but with a mind so framed that should you require not to be so, you may be able and know how to change to the opposite”. Each formula is a paradox only so long as its second column is kept out of sight, and Machiavelli knew where the column was kept. In the twenty-first chapter he set down the law that governs them all: “Never let any Government imagine that it can choose perfectly safe courses”, since “it is found in ordinary affairs that one never seeks to avoid one trouble without running into another”. The prince has read that chapter too. He took it for advice to other governments.

Newton wrote the same law for bodies, which are in no position to plead an exception: “To every action there is always opposed an equal reaction.” He illustrated it with an example a prince could follow, “If you press a stone with your finger, the finger is also pressed by the stone”, and with a horse that draws a stone on a rope and is drawn back towards it as hard, since the rope “will obstruct the progress of the one as much as it advances that of the other”. The two forces are a single interaction read from the two bodies it joins, which is exactly what the prince’s safety and his exposure are, read from the two sides of his frontier. He has his finger on his subjects and calls the pressure security. It is returned at the same strength, on the side he has stopped watching: whatever he takes from their power to rise against him he takes, to the ounce, from their power to rise for him. The best of both worlds is a contradiction with good manners. It passes for a paradox until somebody presents the bill.

III. Routed in the Field

The consolation the prince takes from the chapter carries its own refutation, in a subordinate clause. Whoever attacks the Turk, he warns, “will find him united”, and must rely on his own strength rather than on revolts. So far the prince is pleased. But the sentence runs on: “if once the Turk has been conquered, and routed in the field in such a way that he cannot replace his armies, there is nothing to fear but the family of this prince, and, this being exterminated, there remains no one to fear”. Why should the Turk be unable to replace his armies? Because he has abolished everyone who could raise one. A King of France who loses a battle still has his lords, with men and castles of their own and a stake in the outcome, and the conqueror who has beaten him in the field has only begun. A Turk who loses one has servants, and the servants have nothing of their own to defend and nothing of their own to defend it with. Hard to take turns out, on inspection, to mean hard to take by intrigue. By force the kingdom is exactly as hard to take as its army is to beat, and not a day longer: once the field is won there are no sieges, no pacification, no rebellions to put down for a generation. The Turk of Machiavelli’s day was a conquering power, and a kingdom of servants that is conquering looks invincible; the arrangement shows its price only on the day its army is beaten in the field, which is why princes believe in it and conquerors collect on it.

Sparta paid on such a day. The Thebans, who had beaten its army at Leuctra, came down the valley of the Eurotas burning as they went, and the citizens of a city without walls found themselves a handful. The authorities offered freedom to any Helot who would take up arms, and Xenophon records the result: “More than six thousand helots, it is said, enrolled themselves, so that a new terror was excited by the very incorporation of these men.” The danger the city had spent its history keeping down was the only reserve it had left, and at the hour of the enemy it could neither do without it nor bear to look at it.

Machiavelli’s own example was Darius, whose kingdom was of the Turk’s kind, and the outcome fits in a line: “Darius being killed, the state remained secure to Alexander.” The kingdom of barons has to be conquered many times over, a castle and a grudge at a time, and is never quite held; the kingdom of servants is conquered once, and held ever after by whoever happened to win. Machiavelli adds, for the conqueror’s comfort, that the servants will give him no trouble afterwards, since he did not rely on them before his victory and need not fear them after it. He might have put it more simply. Men who owe everything to the favour of the man in power owe it, on the day after the battle, to the man in power. The prince took their dependence for loyalty. It was only dependence, and dependence transfers. Arrian shows the transfer under way before the new master had even arrived. Darius, beaten in the field for the second time, was carried east by his own nobles, who had arrested him and resolved “to surrender him to Alexander, and to procure some advantage for themselves, if they should find that Alexander was pursuing them”. When Alexander came close they wounded him and left him there, and he died before Alexander had seen him. The men he had made great were pricing his body for his conqueror. That is what hard to subvert from within had meant all along: not that nobody inside would betray the prince, but that nobody inside would dare to until someone outside had beaten him. He had built a state that would be easy to hold. He had neglected to specify by whom.

One danger remains to the prince who has removed every armed man but his own, and he knows its address. It is the army. Machiavelli noted that the Turk keeps a standing guard of twelve thousand foot and fifteen thousand horse, “on which depend the security and strength of the kingdom”, and must keep it friendly whatever this costs the people. The danger taken from the lords has not left the kingdom; it has moved into the barracks, and the prince, who cannot remove it from there without removing his army, does the next best thing and makes the army too weak to hurt him. He arranges its promotions, its training, its commands and the flow of its information so that no officer can gather enough of any of them to be dangerous, and he has, by the same arrangements, an army that cannot gather enough of them to win. A modern study took the regime that has become the textbook case, a dictatorship so thoroughly proofed against coups that it seemed “unable to generate fighting power commensurate with its resources”, and found that its army fought well in the later years of a long war, after the danger from outside had changed its master’s sense of the threat, and with it his handling of exactly those four things; and that it returned to ineffectiveness once the war was over. An army made safe for its master is an army made safe for his enemies. It can be repaired by fear of them, for as long as the fear lasts.

Machiavelli saw where this ends, in the book he did not dedicate to a prince. A ruler who withholds arms from his subjects, he writes there, incurs “the still greater disadvantage, that the closer an enemy presses you the weaker he finds you”; such states resist a little at their borders and not at all beyond them, for, “leaving the heart undefended, defend only the hands and feet”. The kingdom of servants is the purest case of the type. It has a frontier and a palace and nothing between them that will fight for either: no lord with more to lose from the invader than from the prince, no city that has kept its walls, no general who could raise a second army when the first is gone. It is a shell, and it is very hard to crack from the inside.

IV. The Swifter Ones

There remains a question the prince never asks, because he regards it as answered: where the removed have gone. Some, certainly, are dead. Many are not, since killing is expensive and conspicuous, and a prince who has a frontier has a cheaper method. The swift are sent out, into exile, into embassies, into distant commands, into the service of anyone abroad who is glad to have them. His vocabulary gives the method away. The modern word for what he does to a danger is eliminate, and the trade has come to use it for killing; but Latin made it from limen, a threshold, and meant by it “to turn out of doors”. It never meant destroy. It meant to take a thing from inside the house and set it down outside, where it goes on existing, with everything it knew.

Athens had no prince, only a door, which is all the method requires, and it put Alcibiades through it. He went to Sparta and told the Spartans how to win the war: they were to fortify Decelea, in Attica itself, and he explained why they should take his word for it, since “every one naturally knows best his own weak points and fears accordingly”. He also named the authors of his treason, and they were not the Spartans: “my worst enemies are not you who only harmed your foes, but they who forced their friends to become enemies.” The fort was built, and because of it “more than twenty thousand slaves had deserted, a great part of them artisans”. The danger Athens had put out did not stop being a danger. It stopped being Athenian, and it worked twice over: the city it left was the poorer by one general, and the city it joined the richer by one who knew exactly where to strike.

Consider him at his door, then, and give him his due. He keeps it with a vigilance that does not sleep and a judgement that does not tire. He looks once at each who comes to the threshold and judges by a single property, the only one that matters to him, which is heat: speed, energy, ambition, the capacity to move without being moved. The swift he puts out. The slow he lets in and keeps: the client, the favourite, the official who can be moved about the provinces like a piece on a board. He touches nobody. He does no work that anyone can see, a door opened, a door closed; and by this alone, by sorting, the house grows cool and the street grows hot. Within, there is a quiet he calls order. Without, there is nothing he need consider, since the street is not his house.

There is a portrait of him more exact than any historian’s, drawn by a man who was thinking of something else entirely. In December 1867 James Clerk Maxwell sent his friend Tait a thought experiment. Take a gas in a vessel divided by a partition with a hole in it, and “conceive a finite being who knows the paths and velocities of all the molecules by simple inspection but who can do no work except open and close a hole in the diaphragm by means of a slide without mass”. Let him sort them, and “the hot system has got hotter and the cold colder and yet no work has been done, only the intelligence of a very observant and neat-fingered being has been employed”. Maxwell called it a being. A later catechism he wrote for Tait records who called it something else: “Who gave them this name? Thomson.” The name was demon. The prince has always preferred statesman.

Look at the drawing again, and the prince’s error is in it. The demon does not sit at the edge of the world. He sits at a partition inside a single vessel, and the envelope runs somewhere further out, enclosing him and the street together. The prince has always taken his frontier for the envelope. It was only the division. Nor has the demon made order. He has made a difference, a cold side and a hot side, and a difference is the one thing an engine needs. The law he believes he has broken, in the version that bears Clausius’s name, forbids any cycle with “no other result than” the passage of heat from the colder body to the hotter, and there is always another result: the difference the demon makes “could be exploited by a conventional heat engine to extract work”, and an engine is built by whoever stands where the heat is. Here, then, is the prince’s account, kept in the only units it has ever really been kept in. He measures his safety by the temperature of his house. The engine measures its opportunity by the difference between his house and the street, and every degree he takes out of the one he adds to the other. The quieter he makes his kingdom, the more work there is to be had from it, by someone else.

For a long time the being was a paradox, a creature that seemed to have the best of both worlds, a hot one and a cold one, for the price of a door. The physicist who presented him with the bill was a Hungarian working in Berlin. In 1929 Leo Szilard argued that the second law would be saved if the demon’s knowledge were not free: to sort the molecules he must find out which is which, and the finding out must be paid for. Physicists have quarrelled ever since about where the bill falls, in the seeing, the remembering or the forgetting, and no demon has yet been caught working for nothing. Four years later the country in which Szilard worked began sorting its own people at its frontier, by a criterion that required no knowledge of anyone, and Szilard, who had kept two suitcases packed in his room, used them. He took the train to Vienna close to the first of April 1933: “The train was empty. The same train, on the next day, was overcrowded, was stopped at the frontier, the people had to get out and everybody was interrogated by the Nazis.” He was one of the swifter ones. That September in London, set pondering by a newspaper report in which Rutherford was quoted as calling talk of atomic energy on an industrial scale moonshine, he walked the streets: “I stopped for a red light at the intersection of Southampton Row. As the light changed to green and I crossed the street, it suddenly occurred to me” that an element which emitted two neutrons for every one it absorbed could, in a large enough mass, “sustain a nuclear chain reaction”. Newton had promised the prince an equal reaction. This was the other kind, a reaction that multiplies itself, conceived at a crossing by a molecule a door had let through a day early. In August 1939 Szilard drafted a letter to the President of the United States, and Einstein, who had also left Germany, signed it. The door in Berlin had done its sorting with perfect confidence and at no cost it could see. There is no cycle whose only result is a quiet house; and somewhere, always, a light is changing to green.

V. With Chalk in Hand

The bill is presented to the state, and Machiavelli itemised it in the twelfth chapter of The Prince as though dictating to a notary. A prince who will not trust arms to his own people must buy his defence from strangers, and the strangers are “valiant before friends, cowardly before enemies”. The foreigners came, and “Charles, King of France, was allowed to seize Italy with chalk in hand”, the Pope’s joke being that the French had come “with chalk in their hands, to mark up their lodgings, rather than with swords to fight”. The Venetians had a captain good enough to beat the Duke of Milan and too lukewarm to trust, could neither keep him nor let him go, and were “compelled, in order to secure themselves, to murder him”; with the captains who came after him, at Vaila, “in one battle they lost that which in eight hundred years they had acquired with so much trouble”. Machiavelli named the culprits without a tremor: “as they were the sins of princes, it is the princes who have also suffered the penalty.” Eight hundred years and one battle. Those are the units in which a state made safe from its own defenders keeps its accounts.

Shakespeare gave the last word to a man put out of doors. The tribunes of Rome banish Coriolanus, the general who had saved the city and despised it in about equal measure, its danger and its defence in a single man, which is where the two are usually found; and he turns on them with a curse that is an exact account of the method: “Have the power still / To banish your defenders; till at length / Your ignorance, which finds not till it feels, / Making not reservation of yourselves, / Still your own foes, deliver you as most / Abated captives to some nation / That won you without blows!” Then he goes, to the Volsces as it turns out, at whose head he will come back to the gates, to be turned back only by his mother. The city does not know that yet. As he leaves, the stage fills with the prince’s faith: the citizens shout “Our enemy is banish’d! he is gone!” and throw up their caps. Ignorance, which finds not till it feels. Nobody in the crowd thinks to ask where a man goes when he is put out of doors. He has just told them, in his last words to them, and they took the words for a farewell. They were an address.

There is a world elsewhere.


A World Elsewhere

On a kingdom safe from everyone inside it.

Achraf SOLTANI — November 20, 2026


Sources

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (principal source): Niccolò Machiavelli (Nederman, rev. 2023) · Insolubles (Read and Spade, rev. 2025) · Information Processing and Thermodynamic Entropy (Maroney, 2009).

Primary texts: Machiavelli, The Prince 4, 12, 17, 18, 19 and 21 (Marriott), with Bacon’s History of the Reign of King Henry VII as quoted in Marriott’s note to chapter 12, Discourses on Livy II.30 (Thomson) and History of Florence III.1 (anonymous translation, 1901); Thucydides, History of the Peloponnesian War IV.80, VI.91–92 and VII.27 (Crawley); Xenophon, Hellenica VI.5 (Dakyns); Montesquieu, Considerations on the Causes of the Grandeur and Decadence of the Romans IX (Baker); Arrian, Anabasis of Alexander III.21 (Chinnock); Diogenes Laërtius, Lives of the Eminent Philosophers II.108, as translated in the SEP entry Insolubles, note 2; Newton, The Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy, “Axioms, or Laws of Motion”, Law III (Motte, 1846 edition); Lewis and Short, A Latin Dictionary (1879), s.v. ēlīmino; Shakespeare, Coriolanus III.iii; J. C. Maxwell, letter to P. G. Tait of 11 December 1867 and the catechism “Concerning Demons”, in C. G. Knott, Life and Scientific Work of Peter Guthrie Tait (1911), pp. 213–215.

Secondary: L. Szilard, “On the Decrease of Entropy in a Thermodynamic System by the Intervention of Intelligent Beings”, Zeitschrift für Physik 53 (1929), 840–856, and “Reminiscences”, in D. Fleming and B. Bailyn (eds), The Intellectual Migration (1969); the Einstein–Szilard letter to F. D. Roosevelt, 2 August 1939; R. Landauer, “Irreversibility and Heat Generation in the Computing Process”, IBM Journal of Research and Development 5 (1961), 183–191; C. H. Bennett, “The Thermodynamics of Computation — a Review”, International Journal of Theoretical Physics 21 (1982), 905–940; J. Earman and J. D. Norton, “Exorcist XIV: The Wrath of Maxwell’s Demon”, Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics 29 (1998), 435–471, and 30 (1999), 1–40; C. Talmadge, “The Puzzle of Personalist Performance: Iraqi Battlefield Effectiveness in the Iran-Iraq War”, Security Studies 22 (2013); B. Dowden, “Fallacies”, Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, s.v. Hooded Man; Wiktionary, s.v. eliminate.